EFFECTIVENESS OF MULTICHANNEL MARKETING IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION

ABSTRACT

This article examines the effectiveness of multichannel marketing in the context of digital transformation. It discusses strategies for synchronizing online and offline channels to create a seamless customer journey, including communication consistency, inventory management, and interaction personalization. The impact of mobile applications, social networks, and physical retail locations on marketing strategy is studied, along with their role in shaping user experience. Methods for evaluating the effectiveness of multichannel campaigns, such as attribution models, end-to-end analytics, and others, are explored, as well as their application for optimizing marketing decisions.

АННОТАЦИЯ

В данной статье рассматривается эффективность мультиканального маркетинга в условиях цифровой трансформации. Обсуждаются стратегии синхронизации онлайн- и офлайн-каналов для создания бесшовного клиентского пути, включая согласованность коммуникаций, управление товарными запасами и персонализацию взаимодействия. Изучается влияние мобильных приложений, социальных сетей и физических розничных точек на маркетинговую стратегию, их роль в формировании пользовательского опыта. Исследуются методы оценки эффективности мультиканальных кампаний, такие как модели атрибуции, сквозная аналитика и другие, а также анализируется их применение для оптимизации маркетинговых решений.

Keywords: multichannel marketing, digital transformation, channel synchronization, mobile applications, social networks, retail network, personalization.

Ключевые слова: мультиканальный маркетинг, цифровая трансформация, синхронизация каналов, мобильные приложения, социальные сети, розничная сеть, персонализация.

Introduction

In the contemporary era of digital advancement, marketing practices are also evolving dramatically. The old models of consumer interaction are increasingly being replaced by a multichannel approach that brings digital platforms in conjunction with conventional channels to provide a smooth and uninterrupted customer experience (CX). The use of multiple channels such as social media, mobile apps, online platforms, and physical stores enhances audience engagement and yields better conversion ratios. The efficacy of such a system is largely dependent on the unified use of channels and strategic deployment of data analysis.

An essential aspect of multichannel marketing is to maintain a harmonious balance between digital channels of interaction and physical channels. Consumer anticipates a personalized experience that is coherently connected across channels. Social networking sites and mobile phone apps offer unprecedented levels of engagement, offering immediate information access and personalized guidance, but traditional retail stores are still a majority of the buying experience.

Despite the ubiquity of multichannel solutions, their success remains questionable. One of the biggest issues is developing valid methodologies for channel integration success measurement. Traditional marketing metrics are not always well-suited to describe the complex consumer journeys that span many touchpoints. In such cases, analysis that is informed by data is particularly helpful in enabling the identification of behavioral patterns and instant adjustment of marketing strategies.

The aim of this study – to examine the effectiveness of multichannel marketing within the framework of digital transformation. The relevance of this topic is driven by the need to identify optimal strategies that enable businesses to adapt to shifting consumer behaviors and leverage digital technologies to enhance their competitive advantage.

Main part. Synchronization of online and offline channels in multichannel marketing

Modern consumers interact with brands across different touchpoints, including websites, mobile apps, social media sites, emails, and in-store places of business. The process of engagement often displays a nonlinear nature. A consumer, for example, may browse a product online, review its quality in a store, and finally finalize a purchase using a mobile application. Such complex processes require a strategic marketing process that is centered around multichannel integration and a unifying CX.

One of the important aspects of multichannel marketing is communication consistency. Information presented across different channels must be up-to-date, uniform, and personalized according to user preferences. Beyond communication consistency, inventory management and logistics synchronization play a crucial role. It requires online and offline sales integration with real-time product availability updates for offering a seamless shopping experience [1]. To mitigate such issues, firms employ omnichannel inventory management systems (OMS) that consolidate product details across all the platforms and update them in time.

The other area is the seamless movement between channels. Consumers desire to begin their purchasing process on one device and complete it on another without having lost their details. If the user adds a product to their cart on a website, they expect to see the same item when they log into the mobile app. Similarly, return and exchange processes should be equally convenient across both online and offline stores. Achieving this level of consistency requires businesses to implement centralized customer data platforms (CDP) and leverage behavioral analytics to anticipate client needs [2]. Channel synchronization assists in enhancing CX and influencing the effectiveness of marketing campaigns. Businesses can track customers' journeys for the purpose of comprehending the degree to which a channel influences buying decisions.

The successful implementation of multichannel marketing relies on data integration, communication synchronization, and a sound technology infrastructure. Companies that can offer an integrated CX achieve competitive advantage by enhanced consumer loyalty, enhanced conversion rates, and enhanced marketing analytics.

The role of mobile applications, social media, and physical retail networks in marketing strategy

Modern multichannel marketing is built on the seamless integration of various communication channels, with mobile applications, social media, and physical retail locations playing a particularly significant role. Their effective integration enables brands to expand their audience reach and to establish personalized relationships with customers, fostering long-term loyalty. Each of these channels serves a distinct function within a marketing strategy and requires tailored approaches to maximize its effectiveness. According to report [3], search engines and TV advertisements are among the dominant sources, while digital platforms such as social media ads and mobile applications also play a major role (fig. 1).

Figure 1. Sources of brand discovery as of February 2025, %

This highlights the increasing necessity of integrating online and offline channels to enhance brand awareness and customer engagement. Mobile applications have become a key aspect of digital consumer engagement. The platforms provide instant access to services and goods, and at the same time enable brands to provide personalized services based on analysis of consumer behavior. Using push notifications, companies can remind consumers of items remaining in a shopping cart, remind them of expired promotions, and reward purchases of items previously searched. The usage of gamification via apps enhances users' activity, while rewards accumulation, loyalty cards, and interactive elements promote repurchasing as well as brand loyalty.

Social media serves as a fundamental element in brand building and audience interaction. According to the 2024 report [4], nearly 91% of global marketing decision-makers reported using social media as a marketing channel. Apart from its use as an advertisement medium, it also finds application as a means of direct customer interaction. Interactive content like live streaming, user reviews, polls, and challenges generate engagement and build trust in the brand. Other than organic content, paid social media advertising tools also enable precise targeting of the audience. It should also be noted that social media is not only a marketing channel but also a storehouse of consumer opinions. Internet forums, consumer comments, and forums enable businesses to respond to consumer complaints instantly and modify their marketing strategies accordingly.

Despite the rapid growth of digital technologies, physical retail networks remain a crucial component of marketing strategy. Brick-and-mortar stores serve as points of sale and as spaces that provide a unique CX that cannot be fully replicated in a digital environment. Physical touch of products, customized guidance, and brand atmosphere create a deeper emotional connection with customers. Modern shopping malls use digital technology more and more to further enhance the CX. The use of QR codes, touch screens, virtual changing rooms, and cashless payment further simplifies the process of shopping and convenience. Some companies go one step further by creating concept stores offering not only products but also an integrated branded experience.

Hybrid models that integrate both online and offline formats are gaining increasing popularity. The concept of smart retail involves leveraging customer data to personalize in-store interactions. In a case, when a customer has previously placed an order through a mobile application, store employees can suggest additional relevant products during their next visit. Click & collect models are being widely adopted, enabling customers to place orders online and pick them up at a nearby store, bridging the gap between digital convenience and physical shopping experiences [5].

Mobile applications, social media, and physical retail stores serve complementary roles within multichannel marketing. Their seamless integration expands audience reach and facilitates personalized engagement with each customer. It is not enough to simply utilize these channels, because businesses must implement various technologies to continuously adapt their marketing strategies to evolving consumer needs.

Methods for evaluating the effectiveness of multichannel marketing

Multichannel marketing presents different channels of engagement in a business environment. Yet, it also brings different challenges in measurement of performance that deviate from more classic marketing models that typically describe a more linear path of consumer interaction. The multiple touchpoints of multichannel marketing also make it more difficult to assign particular contributions to total results. To enable informed decision making, marketers need to use sophisticated analysis methods that enable the quantification of the impact of each strategic element.

One of the most important instruments of evaluation of multichannel marketing's effectiveness is the use of key performance indicators (KPI). Various other metrics are used to assess the impact of multichannel strategies, as each reflect different aspects of marketing performance and customer behavior (table 1).

Table 1.

Impact of multichannel marketing on key metrics [6, 7]

For a more accurate report, attribution models are applied to determine which channels were behind a customer's purchase decision. The traditional last-click attribution model, which assigns full credit for a conversion to the final touchpoint, is rapidly becoming obsolete in a multichannel environment as it does not take into consideration the impact of prior interactions. Other models are capable of providing a more realistic share of influence via different channels.

The linear attribution model assigns equal weight to all touchpoints within the customer journey, ensuring that each interaction contributing to the brand engagement is recognized as an integral part of the overall conversion process. While this approach provides a more balanced perspective, it does not reflect the varying significance of different stages in the decision-making process. In contrast, the time decay attribution model assigns greater weight to interactions that occur closer to the point of purchase, assuming that they exert the strongest influence on the final decision. Data-driven attribution leverages machine learning (ML) to analyze consumer behavior and dynamically determine the contribution of each channel based on real-world data [8].

In addition to attribution models, businesses increasingly rely on end-to-end analytics, which traces the complete customer journey from initial touchpoint with a brand to final purchase and post-purchase activity. End-to-end analytics brings together data from multiple sources including CRM systems, ad platforms, web analytics, and sales.

The most advanced measure of effectiveness is cohort analysis, which allows for segmentation of the audience according to many different factors such as first interaction or acquisition date and the ability to track behavior patterns across each of these segments. Another useful tool is A/B testing and multivariate testing, allowing for comparison across various versions of ad messages, promotion tactics, and channel mixes. Testing can ascertain which calls to action (CTA) are generating the most conversions or what combination of online and offline touches is most affecting customer engagement and sales.

Modern artificial intelligence (AI) and ML technologies hold one of the main places in analyzing the effectiveness of multichannel marketing. These technologies enable businesses to predict user behavior, uncover hidden patterns in data, and automate campaign optimization processes. These AI-driven algorithms can analyze consumer preferences and deliver real-time personalized recommendations.

Multichannel marketing is not only measured in terms of direct sales numbers but also in terms of overall user behavior metrics, including content interaction and overall level of interaction. The integration of advanced analytics, attribution models, and ML enables businesses to refine their strategy continually, enhance conversion rates, and build long-term customer relationships.

Conclusion

Current multichannel marketing is evolving from a basic promotional function to a strategic approach that allows for personalized engagement of each consumer at every step of their path. The strategic integration of digital channels alongside traditional media enhances the effectiveness of marketing campaigns. Additionally, the thoughtful use of mobile applications, social media platforms, and physical stores, combined with advanced measurement methods, enables companies to optimize their marketing efforts and improve consumer satisfaction. An in-depth analysis of metrics, deployment of ML technologies, and application of advanced methods of attribution help in making strategic adaptations that cater to the constantly evolving consumer behavior patterns.

References:

1. Malikov A. Effective marketing strategies for business development: from traditional methods to digital platforms // International Journal of Humanities and Natural Sciences. 2024. Vol. 12-4 (99). P. 208-213.
2. Lopez J. Empowering Business Strategies with Customer Data Platforms: The Intersection of Big Data and Customer Intelligence for Enhanced Decision Making //Australian Journal of Machine Learning Research & Applications. 2024. Vol. 4. №. 1. P. 1-16.
3. Digital 2025: How people discover new brands / DataReportal // URL: https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2025-sub-section-brand-discovery (date of application: 01.02.2025).
4. Leading marketing channels according to decision-makers worldwide as of March 2024 / Statista // URL: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1477266/top-marketing-channels-worldwide/ (date of application: 03.02.2025).
5. Alexander B., Kent A. Change in technology-enabled omnichannel customer experiences in-store //Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services. 2022. Vol. 65. P. 102338. DOI: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2020.102338 EDN: DEMZTM
6. Israfilov A., Yakovishin A. Protection of privacy and data on the internet. ISJ Theoretical & Applied Science. 2024. Vol 139. №. 11. P. 42-46. DOI: 10.15863/tas.2024.11.139.10 EDN: YTTQHG
7. Farris P.W., Bendle N., Pfeifer P., Reibstein D. Marketing metrics: The manager's guide to measuring marketing performance. FT press; 2021 Jul 27.
8. Rosário A. T., Dias J. C. How has data-driven marketing evolved: Challenges and opportunities with emerging technologies //International Journal of Information Management Data Insights. 2023. Vol. 3. №. 2. P. 100203. DOI: 10.1016/j.jjimei.2023.100203 EDN: BCZIDT